“Not Overjoyed by the American Idol Boy Toys
aired 2/19/08

Well here we are at season seven of American Idol. Seven is supposed to be the year of completion or perfection and the judges promise this will be the best season yet.  Is it just me or do they say that every year? I must admit, I was very skeptical of these claims, because it seems as if the judges, including Simon COWELL, have become much too soft while on their hiatus from the show. That was until they kicked off that crybaby Josiah Lemmon.  I just knew they were going to torture us by keeping that kid on the show, simply because he claimed to be homeless.  Not to mention, that the voting American public would keep him on yet a little longer because they love a sob story.  Once Josiah was kicked off, I again had a little faith in the American Idol judges.

If you’ve read my reviews before, you know that I normally agree with Simon’s take on things. But I guess as time passes, people tend to grow apart. Because lately I find myself totally disagreeing with his opinions of some of the contestants. As a prime example, take the first boy contestant to perform, 24 year-old, David Hernandez. This guy has a great voice, a sincere personality, and frankly he’s not bad to look at. When Simon admitted, that he did not think David should be in the competition, David vowed to take this criticism as a challenge.

David chose the song “Wait Til the Midnight Hour”, by Wilson Picket, as his ‘60’s song. I still like David and he sounded okay, but I really didn’t like his rendition of this soul classic. Randy Jackson liked his vibe on the song, but he advised David to add some long notes to his repertoire. Paula Abdul shocked me by giving very detailed and specific comments, when she commended David on his falsetto and vibrato techniques. Simon said David’s performance was better than he thought it would be. He liked the beginning of the song. However, Simon described the middle of the song as being a little rabbit in the headlights like. And he hated the ending. Then Simon told David that he needed to loosen up a bit. I think Simon is coming around.

Next up was Chikezie, the only African-American male in the contest. We may finally have an African-American man as President of the United States, but is rather doubtful that the winner of AI7 will be an African American male. During season six Chikezie made it to Hollywood, but was eliminated by the judges before the live shows began airing.

Chikezie sang the sound, “More Today Than Yesterday”, which was first recorded by a group called Spiral Staircase.  It has also been covered by Stevie Wonder and of course Diana Ross sang it on American Idol last year. Although I was born in the 60’s (1969), and religiously watch AI, at first I’ve didn’t know what Chikezie was singing.  However, his mom knew and she apparently knew all the words too, because she was singing right along with her baby. I may not have readily known the song, but one thing is for sure, I will never be able to forget that tangerine orange suit he wore.

Randy started off by pointing out that Chikezie is an old fashion singer and as such he recommended that Chikezie try to keep his performances young and fresh. But overall, Randy felt the performance was alright. Paula called Chikezie a throwback to great R&B. She went on to characterize him and his smile as infectious (so is the flu). Paula wrapped by saying Chikezie did a very good job. Simon hated the entire performance. Simon said Chikezie’s suit was hideous (I agree). Simon then labeled Chikezie’s performance as corny and cheesy. Simon summed up by saying the whole thing was old fashion and like something that was filmed 30 or 40 years ago.

Rocker David Cook took the stage next. Sitting backstage prior to his performance, host Ryan Seacrest commented that David seemed way too comfortable. I guess he just has that way about him. David sang the song “So Happy Together”, by The Turtles. In my opinion, David demonstrated exactly what Simon was trying to convey to Chikezie. He took a classic, well-known song from the ‘60’s and made it fresh and current. And in the process, he made it his own. The vocals could have been better, but he got the crowd on their feet and he definitely gets a gold star for originality.

Randy admitted that he was a little leery when he realized what song David was singing. But Randy said David worked it out and managed to turn “So Happy Together” into a rock song. Referring to a comment Simon during David’s initial audition, Paula Abdul said David’s performance was worthy of great praise. Simon couldn’t remember if he had said “wordy” or “worthy” when he first evaluated David’s singing, so he didn’t address Paula’s question when she asked if David’s performance was a worthy one. However, Simon did say that he liked David’s rendition of the song, although he felt like he shouted the middle portion of it.

Next up was Jason Yeager, age 28, from the great state of Texas. You know we do it bigger and better in Texas, so I expected great things from Jason.  I can’t say I was totally disappointed. He sang his song well, but I didn’t really like the song he sang. Jason selected a song called “Moon River”, which apparently Audrey Hepburn sang in the movie “Breakfast at Tiffany’s”. The song was also covered by Frank Sinatra. I’m not sure, whose version Jason was patterning his after, but it almost put me to sleep.

Randy commented that the song Jason chose was a tough one, probably tougher than even Jason knew. Randy also cautioned Jason to stay focused during his performances. Randy said during the middle of the song, he felt like Jason’s mind had gone somewhere else. After co-signing on Randy’s remarks, Paula revealed that she had sentimental ties to the song Jason sang, because she performed her first ballet recital to the tune. This in turn allowed Jason to reveal that he too had sentimental ties to the song. He said his grandmother taught him the song when he was very little. This as his young son lovingly looked on. Grandmothers and children, who wouldn’t vote for this guy? I fully expected him to bring his puppy out on stage next.  Coincidentally, Simon pulled out the puppy remark as well, when Randy asked if he wore his first tutu to this song. After asking Jason how old he was, Simon went on to say that he felt the whole performance was a bit cruise ship like. Simon added that he thought a lot of young people at home would watch Jason’s performance with a huge question mark hovering over their heads. The crowd was not happy with Simon’s remarks, so he hyped them up some more by calling Jason’s performance middle of the road and likening him to an old reliable dog.

Rockers definitely have a presence on this season of American Idol, as it was time for yet another one to take the stage. Yes, it was time for Robbie Carrico to rock out.  But before he sang, Robbie revealed that he used to be a member of a boy/girl group that opened up for Britney Spears. Robbie looked like a rocker, with a red bandana atop of his long blond locks and a standard issue biker’s chain hanging from his jeans, but his song lacked that rocker vibe. Robbie chose the song “One is the Loneliest Number”, made most famous by the band Three Dog Night. Personally, I expect rockers to have more angst when they sing. In my opinion, Robbie’s song was way too mundane.

Randy liked it, saying Robbie moved him. Paula followed up by stating that Robbie picked the perfect song. She called him authentic and commended him on the way he looked. I guess Paula has made it know which boy toy she’ll be keeping her eye on. Even though his comment seemed to go over Robbie’s head, Simon said Robbie’s performance was the only one so far that had any semblance of making sense. Simon disputed Paula’s comment about Robbie being authentic, by saying he wasn’t sure if Robbie was comfortable in the rocker role he had cast himself in. Simon speculated that Robbie might be struggling to decide whether he was a pop singer or a rocker.

Next up was David Archuleta, the 17 year old former winner of Star Search. Let’s face it, this kid can sing. But frankly he’s a little nerve wracking. David sang the classic Smokey Robinson tune “You Better Shop Around” and sang it very well. However, I think he better start shopping around for a new image, or he’ll end up recording those Kidz Bop CD’s or worst performing in Spamalot, alongside Clay Aiken. Seriously, who is going to buy his CD? The good thing is he’s young and there’s plenty of time to discover what will make him commercial.

Randy told David he was a big fan and that he thought David sang the song in a very mature manner. Paula felt it was a very brave and bold song choice and that she forgets all about David’s young age, when he sings. Surprisingly, Simon simply told David that when you got it you got it. Simon added that David had delivered the best performance, by a comfortable mile, thus far.

Before the call for votes, Ryan remarked that David seemed so comfortable on stage. Hello, he has been performing on them for 5 years. He’s not a wet behind the ears performer like Kelly Pickler, who had never been on a plane before AI. This kid is a professional. He knows how to work a crowd.

Danny Noriega followed little David. Danny revealed, in his pre-taped introduction, that he had been cut from the show last year, on his first day in Hollywood. Danny said he learned from that experience to be himself. So he promised to bring his swagger and attitude to the stage and to be hot.  To do this he sang the Elvis hit “Jailhouse Rock”.  Danny’s voice was good and I actually thought the performance sounded alright, but then I took a good look at him. I wasn’t buying it. I expected him to be a little more flamboyant and sassy, after all that’s who he said was. Instead he looked like he was having some sort of fit.

Randy said he loved the fact that Danny knew how to have a good time no matter what was going on. Unfortunately, Randy felt like the song choice didn’t allow Danny to do his thing. Paula cleverly described the performance as kind of warm and almost scalding. Simon was back in form, he told Danny he thought the performance was verging on grotesque. Simon said that if people were tuning in for the first time, they would not think they were watching the best group of people in the country.

After Danny had riled up the judges, Luke Menard was the unlucky contestant, who had to appear on stage next. This 29 year-old was a Season Six reject. I believe he was singing Harry Nilson song “Everybody Talkin”. I say I think, because I couldn’t understand a word this guy was saying, which is funny because the lyrics say “I don’t hear a word.” Well I could hear them. I just couldn’t make them out.

Randy said the song was consistently pitchy all the way through. Paula likened Luke’s voice to Kenny Loggins, particularly the tenderness in it and said she hoped that Luke would pick better songs in the future. Simon said it didn’t matter if the song was pithy or the wrong choice, the only think that mattered was that Luke’s performance was forgettable. I agree and I think he will be leaving the show on Thursday. Oh well, perhaps he can get a job as an Orlando Bloom look-alike.

Speaking of look-alikes, Colton Berry, the self-professed Ellen DeGeneres double, followed what’s his name. I really think Colton picked a good song for his voice. He sang “Suspicious Mind”, by Elvis Presley. I just didn’t like all the weird things he was doing with his face. If he gets to stick around for awhile, Simon he will figuratively beat that characteristic out of him

Randy told Colton that he started off a little rough, but that all in all it was a pretty good performance. Paula said she didn’t think it was Colton’s best performance, but that he gave it an eager and fun attempt. Right before Simon critiqued his performance, Colton managed to conjure up yet another one of those weird facial expressions. Referring to Danny, Simon said Colton’s performance wasn’t quite as bad as the other Elvis song. Simon then broke it down, saying that the objective of the American Idol competition is to find a recording artist. And the only thing he gathered from Colton’s performance was a kid that could possibly have a career in musical theater. Simon harshly, but accurately, added that Colton has no relevance in today’s music industry.

The look-alike theme was running rampart as Garrett Haley, a toss up between a Leif Garrett and Peter Frampton reincarnate (I hope he doesn’t age as badly as they did), took to the stage. Unlike the other 17 year-old in the competition this kid seems likable. He’s a little shy, but that could definitely be re-packaged as that James Dean, Luke Perry, John Mayer too cool for words attitude.

Garrett sang the tear-jerking tune, “Breaking Up is Hard to Do”, by Mr. Neil Sedaka. Unlike Luke, who attempted, but failed, to show his tender side with his voice, Garrett actually managed to pull it off.

Randy said he loved the song, but Garrett failed to do anything with it. Randy advised Garrett to take the songs and make them his own. Ultimately, though, Randy deemed the performance as boring. Basically, Paula suggested Garret be more courageous with the songs and experiment a little bit with their arrangements. Simon also said the performance was boring, but he didn’t stop there. He said Garrett sounded whiny and looked terrified. He also told the poor kid that he looked paled and needed to get some sun.

Jason Castro, another Texan, graced the stage after Garrett. This dread laden musician took to the stage with his guitar and accompanied himself as he sang the Art Garfunkel song, “Daydream”.  This one is definitely a relevant artist. I liked him and he falls in line with my premonition that a Hispanic will win this year. And since there are no Hispanic females (unless you count the Mercado girl), it would have to be a Hispanic male. I was thinking that it would David Hernandez, but I might have to revise my thinking.

Randy dug the vibe Jason was going for with the guitar, but he did point out a few pitch problems.  All in all, though, Randy thought the performance was alright. Paula said she felt Jason nailed it with his “less is more take” on the song. Simon surprised Jason by saying that he thought his performance was in the top two for the night. Simon added that like David Archuleta, Jason just has it. Then once again he tried to drive home the point that it doesn’t matter how old a song is, you can make it current.

Last but not least, we heard from native Australian Michael John.  Michael, one of the more seasoned members of the group, at age 29, blew me away during Hollywood week. As a result, I had high hopes for him.  With his rendition of The Doors, “Light My Fire”And, boy did he come correct. Michael had a scarf around his neck, but judging from the screaming ladies in the audience, I’m pretty sure it was hot in there.

Randy said he loved Michael because he throws caution to the wind. Randy added that every time he sees Michael its like seeing a true rock legend perform. Paula gushed that it was an excellent way to end the show and that Michael did set everyone on fire. Simon said that Michael was the most consistent contestant in the competition. Simon rounded out his comments by telling Michael that he had the natural charisma of a lead singer and once again Simon remarked that a contestant has just got it. Frankly, I think Michael will get votes based on his speaking voice alone. He certainly has mine.

“The Young Girls Intend to Last, but the Nice Girls Finish Fast”
aired 2/20/2008

On Wednesday night, the American Idol Season Seven girls got their time to shine. But before they performed, host Ryan Seacrest just had to let us know that some of the girls had been suffering from that insufferable flu that’s going around. Not coincidentally, in my opinion, the first girl up was one of those afflicted with the malady.

Kristy Lee Cook, the 24 year-old horse trainer, from Selma, OR, who had to sell one of her horses to pay for her trip to the AI7 auditions, performed first. Kristy chose the song “Rescue Me”. Kristy can definitely blow and she already has a star worthy name, but she seemed rather uncomfortable on the stage. I kept thinking she has to be one of the sick ones, because she literally looked like she was in pain. And that was before it was revealed by Paula Abdul that she, in fact, was one of the afflicted ones.

Judge Randy Jackson acknowledged Kristy was probably nervous being that she was the first one out. Then he told her the performance wasn’t one of her best ones and that it had pitch problems. He summed it up by saying the performances was rough around the edges. As I said earlier, Paula confirmed my suspicions that Kristy was one of the sick ones. Even so, Paula advised Kristy to not let that get in the way of her shine or emote. Simon Cowell could care less if Kristy was sick. He said he didn’t get a lot out of the performance and that the song didn’t suit her. In fact, Simon called Kristy’s performance robotic and the song the complete wrong choice.

Plus –size model Joanne Borgella (what a lovely name), chose the song “I Say A Little Prayer for You”, by Dionne Warwick. This was seemingly the perfect song for this 25 year-old from Hoboken, NJ, since she has such an understated, sweet voice, similar to Ms. Warwick’s. However, it sounded like Joanne’s microphone was turned down too low, because I couldn’t understand a word she was saying. I know she’s not a belter, but it actually sounded like she was mumbling the song.

Once again Randy attributed the poor performance to nerves. He elaborated by stating that Joanne’s voice sounded a little shaky and unsure. Paula made a point to mention that they had seen Joanne before, when she had confidence. Paula started lecturing Joanne by telling her to pull it together and shine through it.  Simon tried to help the audience out, by interpreting Paula’s remarks. He asked Paula if she liked the performance or not to which she responded, “I liked it, but I didn’t love it”

Once Simon clarified Paula’s remarks, he frankly told Joanne that he didn’t like her performance at all. Amid boos from the crowd Simon continued, saying this is the point where you got to bring it. And that her rendition of the song was like a very average cabaret performance. He added that there was no confidence in her vocals and nothing that would make him say this girl would make a great recording artist.

The cameraman cut to whom I assume was Joanne’s father and he was looking at Simon like he was to jump over the judging table and kick the living daylights out of him. 

Unfortunately, Simon was not finished with his tirade. He went on to say that he doesn’t accept the part about nerves. He said the contestants have a head start on becoming a star through the show and if they don’t grab hold of it, they don’t deserve to win.

Poor little Alaina Whitaker, the youngest contestant in the competition, had to the inopportune task of taking the stage right after all of the controversy. Alaina is currently 16 years-old, but she turns 17 on Thursday. For her birthday present she requested America’s votes, to keep her in the competition. All this and the kid had not even sung her song yet. These kids today expect to get without giving.

Alaina chose the Idol favorite, “I Love You More Today than Yesterday”. And unlike the previous two contestants Alaina seemed quite comfortable on stage.  She just might be getting what she wished for on her birthday, a return engagement.

Randy exclaimed that season seven was turning out to be the year of the young ones. Then he told Alaina that the beginning of her song was rough, but that she sang it with such conviction and confidence that he “was like what”.  Then he finished with a Randy Jackson catch phrase, ”Show and prove youngun.”  Paula thought the song was very joyful. She pointed out that the great Diana Ross sang the song on the same stage and that Alaina nailed it. Paula finished by saying something I found quite strange (what else is new). She said that Alaina had the best ending to the song that she’d ever heard. Simon told Alaina he thought she was very good and that for the first time he didn’t see any nerves. Simon hated the song, though. In fact, he said he didn’t even know what it was. I guess he had earplugs on when Diva Ross belted it out last year on their show.

Following Alaina was one of my favorite girl contestants, the rocker nurse Amanda Overmyer. Although I personally would be scared if Amanda was my nurse, I like her style. She sang a song called “Baby Please Don’t Go” and I really liked her performance. However, I think the reason I liked it so much had more to do with the band than Amanda’s singing.  I think she is use to being in a group and sharing the spotlight with the musicians. But the AI competition is about showcasing individual vocals, and I don’t think she did that.

Randy, of course, loved the bluesy, rocker thing and the scatting. Randy also raved over Amanda’s colorful patchwork, denim trouser. (They were cute).  Paula said she loved Amanda because she was authentic and not a one trick pony, whatever that means at this stage of the competition. Simon said he really like Amanda because she was authentic and stood out in the crowd (And isn’t that what it’s all about people).  Simon went on to say that he didn’t think it was Amanda’s best performance. Simon also confused Amanda’s scatting with forgetting the words to the songs.

Next up was Amy Davis, another model this time of the tradeshow variety. This 25 year-old tragically picked the Patsy Klein tune “Where the Boys Are”. Amy seems like a real nice girl, but her performance was musical torture.

Randy simply told Amy that her performance was not great, although he was nice enough to tell her why. Randy explained that when you scoop up to the note you have to be dead on and apparently Amy was not. Randy also said there were pitch problems. Paula had nothing nice to say, so she immediately went to her kiss of death comment about the camera loving Amy.  Paula tried to throw in some meat, by telling Amy that song was not the most engaging and that it was a little lack luster. When it was his turn, Simon claimed he had nothing much to add. Then he said it was what it was (I hate that saying). Somehow Simon found some comments to convey and he told Amy she looked great but didn’t sound great. After telling Amy that her performance was boring, Simon informed her that she needed that country twang to make the song she chose work and that she didn’t have it.

Poor Amy, I don’t think we’ll get a chance to get to know her better. 

Brooke White, another nice girl, who Simon is intent on bringing to the dark side, graced the stage after Amy. Brooke sang the ditty “So Happy Together”.  I can just see her performing this song on Sesame Street or whatever kid show that’s popular now.  The song started off bad, but she quickly got back on track. I just really feel like she should have left the scatting out, especially when she put her hand on head. I think she was trying to look seductive, but she came across looking ditzy and confused. Is scat short for scatterbrain?  I liked David Cook’s version much better than her, good thing she’s not competing against him right now.

Randy also thought the song started off rough. However by the middle of the song, he thought she got her confidence back. As a matter of fact, Randy said she slayed it, which as we later found out means to sing the living daylights out of it.  Paula commended Brooke on being original and having her own thing, because that is what the competition is about. Simon said that Brooke picked the right song, but that she makes him feel like he’s in a 1960’s commercial for washing up liquid (that’s dishwashing liquid to you and me).

The sixth contestant to perform was feisty Alexandréa Lushington. After being inundated with all the ho-hum performances that preceded her, this 17 year-old was a breath of fresh air. The girl has star stage presence. She reminds me of a young Lauren Hill or an even younger Alicia Keys. She sang a song that according to Randy was called “Blood, Sweat and Tears”. I don’t think the arrangement was the best one to showcase her voice and youth, but it she was so exciting to watch it didn’t really matter.

Randy exclaimed once again that season seven is about being young. He also said Alexandréa blew the doors off with her performance. Paula commended Alexandréa on taking control of her performance, taking things like her entrance and outfit into consideration. To Simon, Paula half asked if Alexandréa was relevant.  Apparently, Simon didn’t think that she was, because he said he didn’t get her performance. What’s more Simon said the performance reminded him of some terrible ‘60’s musical (he must have been miserable growing up) and that Alexandréa’s vocals were not hot.

That H-town chick Kady Malloy was next up. Traditionally, Simon has not shown Houston any love and I was anxious to see what he would say about the young singer. Kady sang the song “Groovy Kind of Love”. Since she is a whiz at impersonating other singers, she should have channeled her inner Phil Collins. Because when it comes to finding her own voice, Kady seems to get a little lost.

Randy said he thought she was going to belt out the song when she stood up, but instead it seemed as if she lost her concentration. Paula struggled to find the words to tell Kady that she wanted to see the real her. Simon likened Kady’s performance to the night of the living dead. He told her that when she is impersonating Brittney Spears she’s brilliant, but when she’s herself the lights literally go off. Simon then implied that only a pencil could impersonate Kady. I take it Simon is still not impressed with singers from my hometown.

After the Kady tongue lashing Asia’H Epperson appeared on stage. She sang the Janis Joplin tune “Piece of my Heart”. Asia’H is full of stage presence, personality and confidence, but in my opinion she struggled with the vocals. I was sure it was going to be revealed that she too was sick. But alas it wasn’t so.

The dawg was totally impressed with Asia’H and he told her that she did her thing. Paula said she could tell Asia’H had fun and that there were some really good moments in her song. Undaunted, Simon professed that Asia’H’s performance was his favorite. The judges seemed to keep their comments brief, probably in the interest of time, or perhaps because they didn’t really have much to say.

Ramiele Malubay, the little girl with the big voice was up next. Ramiele sang Dusty Springfield’s “You Don’t Have To Say You Love Me”.  To that point, I thought Ramiele had the best vocals, but I thought her overall performance was kind of drab.

Randy loved that Ramiele took her time and stuck to the melody of the song. In addition, he told her she sang the song like a pro. Paula said Ramiele was a force to be reckoned with. Paula also expressed her hoped that Ramiele goes all the way. Simon started off by admitting that he didn’t, like Ramiele when he first saw her. However, he stated that she was the most consistently good singer during the Hollywood round and that she out sung everyone tonight.

Syesha Mercdo a working actress, who lost her voice during Hollywood week, was not ailing on Wednesday night. With the song “Tobacco Road”, Syesh blew poor little Ramiele’s performance into oblivion.  Not only were her vocals on point, I was totally enthralled by her performance. So far I think that Syesha and the rocker nurse are the two female forces to be reckoned with this year.

Randy told Syesha that she definitely had a big old voice, but that there were pitch problems with the performance. He added that it was not his favorite performance from her. Paula called Syesha’s performance consistent, joyful, fun and big. Simon said it wasn’t her best performance. However, he said that didn’t matter because she is one of the most talented girls in the competition.

Carly Smithson, the 24 year-old tattoo shop owner, closed the show out. Carly is the girl that’s causing quite a stir because she already had a recording contract. Carly used her taped introduction to explain that she got the contract when she was 15, put her record out when she was 17, and was left in the dust when her record company imploded. I don’t care how long ago it was, you had a contract so you are not an amateur. Besides, I really don’t think the girl is all that. She actually reminds me a little of Katharine McPhee. They both sing in this emotionless, soulless and very mechanical manner that does move me at all. I think the name of the song Carly sang was called “The Shadow of Your Smile”, but I really was interested enough to find out.

Naturally Randy loved her. He fawned over her just like he did Kat McPhee. Randy went so far as to say that Carly had the best vocals of all 24 AI7 contestants (Come on dawg, better than Syesha and that cute Australian guy. I don’t think so). Paula called Carly the lucky coin in the pocket and reliable. Simon was the only person whose judgment wasn’t too clouded to give an honest review. He told Carly that he didn’t get her performance nor did he understand the hype surrounding her. He ended by saying everything about Carly was a let down.

“Dawn of the Davids”
aired 2/27/2008

Judge Randy Jackson keeps saying that American Idol Season Seven (AI7) is the year of the young ‘uns. But I say it is the year of the Davids, at least for the boys. Tuesday night was 70’s night and once again the boys were up first. And the young men, who delivered the best performances, were all named David. However, in my opinion, contestant David Hernandez was the one that stood out the most.

There were memorable moments from the other contestants too, starting with Michael John. But before he sang he, like all the other contestants, told us something about himself that he thought would be shock us. Michael’s tidbit of information is that he loves to play tennis. Interesting yeah, but the thing I will remember most about Michael’s performance is that it was not that good. It seemed like he got off key and just couldn’t get back on. This guy can really sing and that accent of his is really hot, so he will likely be okay.

Michael sang Fleetwood Mac’s “Go Your Own Way” and Simon Cowell chided him for coasting. Simon said the song was a weak choice and that the performance had no moment.

Next up was another one of my favorites to win, Jason Castro. Jason revealed that he did not like all the interviews and talking that comes with being an AI7 contestant. Poor Jason just wants to sing. Well maybe he should have listened to his heart and just sang his song, instead of trying to sing and play the guitar. Jason sang and strummed the Andy Gibb song “I Just Want to be Your Everything”. Even though he wasn’t one of the best on 70’s night, I still like Jason and I think he’ll be sticking around, for awhile, to show us what he’s got.

Randy thought the vocals were okay, but somewhat karaoke like. Paula Abdul, on the other hand, felt Jason made a clever song choice and she liked the way he musically interpreted the song. Simon said he thought the song didn’t suit Jason and that he looked uncomfortable singing it.

Luke Menard, the remaining look-alike in the contest, followed Jason. I say he looks like Orlando Bloom, whereas host Ryan Seacrest says he looks like the guy on Dawson’s Creek (James Van Der Beek). Before Luke sang, he revealed that he used to be part of an a cappella group called Chapter 6. I got to say that really didn’t surprise me. However, I was quite shocked by the song he sang. Luke sang the tune “Killer Queen”, by the group Queen. I have to say, I hated it.

Randy simply stated that Luke chose a tough song. Paula as usual was on a different wavelength. She said that Luke picked the perfect song and that it was great for him vocally. Simon thought Luke made a mistake by picking the song, because he would always be judged by the original. Then Simon went one step forward and stated that the original singer had charisma and personality, but Luke does not. Can you say ouch? I think Luke will be saying goodbye on Thursday night.

Appearing fourth was Robbie Carrico, who thought we would be surprised to learn that he drag races. I, for one, was not. In fact, I think Robbie is the poster boy for drag racing. Anyway, Robbie, the confused rocker, selected the Foreigner song, “Hot Blooded”, which ended up leaving us all cold.  I really like Robbie and think he will be around for one more round, but I don’t think he’s exciting enough to go all the way.

Come judgment time, Randy said he didn’t think Robbie’s voice had enough umph in it. Paula thought Robbie played it safe and as a result lost his personality. Robbie was beginning to crack under the pressure and surprisingly Simon was the one that tried to put him at ease. Simon advised Robbie not to be so defensive. Simon followed up by telling Robbie that his vocals were ok.

Little Danny Noriega followed Robbie and he thought he’s shock us by revealing that he was in a punk rock band, when he was in the 9^th grade. Got to say, I’m still not surprised. Now, I was surprised when Danny sang. I didn’t know he could be so soulful. He sang the song “Superstar” ala the 70’s sister and brother group the Carpenters. Although most of us know the song as a big Luther Vandross hit. Anyway, Danny did a great job with the song. I totally enjoyed it.

Randy gave Danny some advice on his technique. Randy recommended Danny speed up his bravado. Randy went on to say he felt like Danny was thinking during his song and that he should just let it go. Paula first commended Danny on his amazing vocal skills and then she cautioned him not to over think and to just perform. Lastly, Simon said he felt Danny’s performance was better than last week’s, although not fantastic. He too believed Danny was over concentrating. All in all, Simon said he like Danny because he stands out. Then Simon shocked me and apparently Danny, by saying Danny looked terrific on camera. It’s funny because, just prior to Simon saying that my husband walked into the room, saw Danny performing and said, “I thought the guys were performing tonight.”

After Danny, close but no cigar, performed, it was time for the first of the David’s to perform. First up was my early pick to win this season, David Hernandez. David selected one my favorite songs from the 70’s, “Pappa was a Rolling Stone”, by the Temptations. Even though, I wished David H would have put more soul and fewer facial expressions into his performance, I still think he is poised to go all the way.

When David finished singing, Randy readily exclaimed this is the David Hernandez we fell in love with. Randy topped off his remarks with a signature “that was hot”. Paula gushed that David’s voice was so pure that it pierces right through the heart (I like him but I think that’s laying it on just a little thick). Simon said that David had the best vocals of the night, so far. He also praised David for taking it as a challenge and not sulking when he’s criticized. Again Simon admitted he wasn’t a fan of David’s, at first. However Simon said he’s now quite happy to hold his head up and say he’s a David Hernandez fan.

Poor Jason Yeager, with his lackluster performance, had the pleasure of following David H. Jason chose a Doobie Brothers song, called “Long Train Running (Without Love)”. I think it was a good song choice, in theory. When I wasn’t looking at the television, Jason had a soulful Terrence Trent Darby sound. But when I looked at him, he exuded the persona of Donnie Osmond. In fact, he looked just like he guy Marie Osmond danced with on the Dancing with the Stars, except his moves were not quite as good. I just don’t think Jason has what it takes to win. He can sing, but I don’t think he will pull enough votes to sustain him another week.

Randy wondered why Jason picked the song when he had so many amazing songs to choose from. Randy went on to explain that the song is not a singer’s song. In the end, Randy said he just didn’t get it. Paula echoed Randy’s sentiments, by stating that Jason picked a song that didn’t show his vocal range. I thought Randy and Paula’s comments were insightful and helpful, but Simon’s were verging on brutal. He said whilst Jason was just boring last week, this week he was awkward and horrific. But Simon didn’t stop there.  He continued by saying Jason performed like he was drunk at a party. Simon wrapped by telling Jason he was a good singer that doesn’t perform well.

Chikezie was up next and he revealed that his name means “something well created by GOD”, in Nigerian. He also revealed that we’re all (not just Simon) pronouncing his name incorrectly, but he’s cool with it. Chikezie picked the Danny Hathaway song “I Believe” as his 70’s song. His vocals were on point, but I still think he’s performance was a little cheesy.

Randy claimed Chikezie was back and he was glad for it. Paula thought Chikezie’s performance was very clever, as well as brilliant and fun. Simon told Chikezie that he looked better, sounded better and that his performance was a million times better than last time.

Simon should have left it at that, but when Simon asked if Chikezie would wear his suit again, Chikezie said he couldn’t wear the same thing twice, on television. Accordingly to Chikezie, only Simon does that. Score: Simon 1 , Chikezie 2. I think that jab, not his performance will keep Chikezie in the competition another week.

David Cook, who’s quickly becoming another one of my favorite male contestants, appeared after Chikezie. I already loved him, because of his voice, but when David C. revealed he was a fellow word nerd, the love deepened. David C. said people would probably be shocked to find out he loves crossword puzzles and word searches, and just words in general. As a writer, those are some of my favorite hobbies so I could totally relate to David C. Plus I think he has star quality

David C. performed the song “Hard Ride” and Randy really liked it. In fact, Randy said it was smart choice of song and that David C. is the real rocker. Paula called David C. the real deal. She also said that his performance was very smart, fun and relevant. Simon thought the performance was solid and believable, but David’s personality was boring and lacking of charisma. David may have ruffled some feathers, when he stated that he didn’t have to impress Simon only the audience. Even so, I believe David is safe for a few more weeks.

Finally, little David Archuleta the forecasted frontrunner came to the stage. David A. sang the John Lennon song “Imagine”. Although his vocals were on point, the song had no passion in it. This song should reek of pain and heartbreak and David’ version just seemed too mechanical to me. I think music is supposed to move you and there was nothing moving about it to me.

I may not have been moved, but Paula surely was. She was moved to tears. She also made some disturbing remarks about wanting to hang David A. on her rearview mirror. I don’t know, it sounds a little stalkerish to me. Anyway, Randy said he thought David’s rendition of “Imagine”, were the best vocals he’s ever heard on the show. I’m a little disappointed, because Simon’s on the David A. bandwagon too. He even told the kid that he thought he was the one to beat this season.

No Surprises for American Idol Season Seven Girls”
aired 2/27/2008

The 12remaining American Idol girls got their chance to bring their special twist to some ‘70’s hits on Wednesday night. But before they sang, the girls, like the boys, were charged with revealing a fact, which they felt America would be surprised to know about them.

First up was Carly Smithson. Carly revealed that in addition to owning and operating a tattoo shop she also works at an Irish bar, one that only hires Irish people. Can someone get the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission on the phone? Carly also said she loves to cook and clean. Carly sang the song “Go Crazy on You”, by the band Heart. What is there to say about her performance, except that Carly can sing; blah blah blah.

Randy Jackson thought the beginning of Carly’s song was rough and that she over sang some of the notes (more like the entire song), but he thought she got it together by the end of the song. Paula Abdul said it was obvious that Carly loved
Heart. Paula also said she was glad to hear Carly back healthy. Simon Cowell said it was a much better performance than last week, but that Carly had yet to connect to the right song. Then Simon eloquently expressed what I’ve been saying about Carly. Simon stated that he didn’t think the other girls in the competition could touch Carly vocally, but that she has not found that moment. I doubt she ever will. Simon also labeled Carly as the one to beat

Syesha Mercado followed Carly. She revealed (yet again) that she was a working actress in Miami and that she had done a lot of commercials. She also treated us to her special talent – imitating a crying baby. When it came her time to sing, Syesha chose the Billy Paul song, “Me and Mrs. (Mr.) Jones”. I liked it. And I thought it was about time that a girl sang the song. In fact, I was doing my best to sing along with her.

Randy told Syesha that he didn’t think it was a great song choice. He felt like she needed a big song to show off her big voice. Randy also said that Syesha seemed uninterested while she sang. Paula said she liked Syesha’s interpretation of the song, but she criticized her for getting off key on the softer notes. Simon said he thought Syesha’s song choice was a bit indulgent and reiterated Randy’s sentiment, when he commented that the song was not a clever choice. I don’t know what the judges were hearing. I would much rather download Syesha’s song than Carly’s.

Brooke White was up next. And she mistakenly thought America would be shocked to learn that she is a beauty school dropout. I have to say that I’m not even the least bit surprised. Armed with her guitar, Brooke belted out the Carly Simon tune, “You’re So Vain” and it seemed as if she was directing the song right at the man who swore to bring her over to the dark side. Brooke’s performance was by no means my favorite one of the night, but just like the judges, I thought the song was perfect for her.


Although Randy thought the song was perfect for Brooke, he didn’t feel like she brought anything new to it. Paula said the song suited Carly and that she liked the familiarity Brooke brought to it. Undoubtedly because he thought she was singing about him, Simon exclaimed that he absolutely loved it.

Ramiele Malubay was fourth at bat and although she didn’t hit it out that park, I believe she did a good job. However, I don’t believe she succeeded in surprising us. The Ramiele shocker was she took Polynesian dance lessons, when she was a little girl. I might be surprised to learn that she was an auto mechanic or bodyguard, but not a former dancer. Anyway back to her singing. Ramiele sang the Thelma Houston version of “Don’t Leave Me This Way”. Ramiele started the song off great, but it sounded like she fell out of key and struggled to get back in tune.

Randy immediately gauged the performance as a little rough. Randy acknowledged Ramiele’s ability to sing but said this song choice was not his favorite. In response to the title Simon bestowed on Carly earlier, Paula said that because her vocals are truly amazing, Ramiele was also the one to be beat. Simon was astonished to find himself agreeing with Paula. Whilst Simon hated the song Ramiele sang, he said he thought Ramiele was one of the 3 best singers in the competition (I guest that would be behind David Archuletta and Carly Smithson).

That brings us to Kristy Lee Cook, who still failed to shock or surprised me with her revelation that she is a tomboy. Hello, you train horses. I could have easily guessed that you prefer hi jinx to high heels. Anyway Kristy sang the Linda Ronstadt song “You’re No Good”.  Compared to the four girls that performed before her, Kristy is simply no good. However, if you take her vocals alone and eliminate that awkward dancing she did, she’s a pretty good singer.  I think she should only sing songs that allow her to stay seated.

Randy emphatically stated that Kristy’s performance was a 100% improvement from last week’s, but that she still failed to show him any breakout moments. Paula simply stated that it was a good song choice. Simon frankly quipped that he couldn’t remember what Kristy sang last week. He added that he didn’t know how to label her and that he thought it would be easier for her if she went the country route. Simon also threw in he thought Kristy had real potential.

Amanda Overmyer was the only one who came close to surprising me with her taped tidbit. Amanda revealed she was a book worm. Although I relished Amanda’s thirst for knowledge, I was thoroughly disappointed with her performance. Not to mention, she looked like the living dead.

Amanda chose the Kansas song, “Carry on Wayward Son” for her 1970’s performance and the judges weren’t to thrill with the choice. Randy said it wasn’t the right song for Amanda, because it had way too much melody. Then he kind of echoed what I said last week about Amanda relying too much on the band. When it was her turn, Paula actually gave Amanda some good advice. She told Amanda to stop worrying about doing too much Janis (Joplin) and to do what’s right for her. Simon as usual was the harshest with his criticism. He said that the performance felt contrived and he couldn’t wait for it to be finished.

Alaina Whitaker got her birthday wish. She received enough votes to stay in the competition one more week (be careful what you wish for). This now 17 year old, tried to shock us by revealing her totally mature aversion to different foods touching, on her plate. Well, I can assure you, if Alaina ever becomes a mother, that attitude will quickly change. Anyway, Alaina sang the Olivia Newton-John song, “Hopelessly Devoted to You”.  I wasn’t crazy about the blue dress she wore, but I thought Alaina did a good job singing the song. Much better than the two girls that performed before her.

The general consensus from the judges was Alaina did a good job, but she didn’t pick the right song. Simon rounded out the comments by calling Alaina one of the dark horses in the races. However, he said she needed to make herself relevant.

Alexandréa Lushington followed Alaina and she revealed that she was once the poster child for the Atlanta Fire Department. In addition, she once did an impromptu performance and Ground Zero in New York. I have to admit that tidbit of knowledge was pleasantly surprising. I also found the song Alexandréa picked a bit surprising. She sang the easy listening hit “If you Leave Me Now”, by Chicago.  A beautiful song, no doubt, but I guess Alexandréa missed the part about her standing out because she is young, hip and fresh. I loved that song and I like this girl, but man that performance was really stale.

Randy scolded Alexandréa for giving a safe and boring performance, when she has mad vocal skills. Paula thought Alexandréa made the performance her own and relevant. Simon said he was a big fan of Alexandréa in the early stages of the competition, but he said she picked a song that has never been covered primarily because it’s stuck in its time period.

I really hoped Alexandréa could have stuck around for a while. However, now that she has been kicked off I hope someone picks her up. I suggest she drops her last name and just goes by Alexandréa. Then she should be groomed as the next Ciara (if she can dance) or Rhiana. I honestly think she has that kind of potential

My homegirl Kady Malloy was up next and she actually had something surprising to divulge. Kady revealed that she sang opera. And surprisingly she sang it quite well. That’s a good thing, because so does hit maker Mariah Carey. Perhaps she should have infused a little Mariah into her voice, because Kady’s performance was an absolute train wreck. I not even sure what song she was singing. I think it was called “Magic Man”. It was so bad, I was tempted to channel surf during her performance.

Randy was pretty intolerant of the performance. In fact, he told Kady she never found the right note and that the performance just didn’t work. As always, Paula looked on the bright side and told Kady that when she powered she sounded great. However, even Paula had to admit that Kady lost it on the low notes. Paula went on to point out that Kady has many hidden talents, but that she just needs to define them (interpretation: get off of our stage and go discovers some of them). Simon said he was surprised that Kady was struggling so much. He added that everything she does on tape is great, but that when she comes on stage it all falls apart. To me that means she should become an actress or go to Vegas and become a celebrity impersonator. People make a good living do that. Or perhaps she should become a comedian, that’s how Jaimie Foxx got his foot in the door.

I’m kind of glad that Kady is still in the competition, but it’s a shame poor Alaina had to be sacrificed just so we can see what this witty, little impressionist will throw at us next.

Last but not least was Asia’H Epperson, whose disappointing surprise was that she once a cheerleader. Give me a break, this bubbly little girl has cheerleader written all over her. If you want to surprise me, tell me Amanda was a former cheerleader.

Asia”H tried to close out the show in a big way with the Eric Carmen hit, “All by Myself”. I honestly didn’t like it and I am really trying to like her. For some reason, I just don’t find myself impressed with her. I mean, she hit the big notes ok, but the rest of the song sounded really amateurish.

Randy made it a point to mention that Asia’H was sick (that might explain some of my disappointment, but hey I thought she sounded sick last week, too). Paula thought Asia’H did great, but that she felt like Asia’H struggled with the low notes. The other judges may not have much to say about Asia’H’s performance but Simon really broke it down. He said the song that Asia’H picked was one of the diva songs of all time and that you have to be one heck of a singer to pull it off. I think poor Asia’H thought Simon was about to congratulate her for being one of those singers, but alas that was not the case. Simon crushed peppy little Asia’H’s spirit, by telling her that unfortunately she was not that good of a singer. Simon said she nearly did it, but that the song was too big for her and that it showed her up. Ouch. I bet those remarks hurt almost as much as being dropped from the top of a pyramid that

The Big and Warm Guy’s 80s Night”
aired 3/05/2008

The eighties will probably be most remembered for big hair and leg warmers. The same can be said for the eight remaining guy’s on American Idol’s 80’s night.  No, their hair wasn’t big and who knows if their legs were warm or not, but their voices could certainly be described as one or the other.

Since 80’s is also known for its embarrassing mark in fashion history, the American Idol producers decided to have the contestants describe their most embarrassment moments. First up was Luke Menard. Luke said his most embarrassing moment involved his older sister, who always wanted a sister, dressing in up like a ballerina. If that wasn’t bad enough, Luke had photographic evidence to support his humiliation. And that wasn’t even the most shameful moment of the night for poor Luke.
 
Luke picked the song, “Wake Me Up Before You Go-Go (Jitterbug)” by George Michael’s former group Wham. As I watched him perform, I kept thinking I can’t believe this guy has gotten this far in the competition.  It’s like he’s not even trying to stay in the contest. He’s practically phoning in his performances. Needless to say Luke’s performance left the judges, lukewarm.

Randy Jackson wanted to know, if Luke had a good time. Probably because no one in the audience did. Randy also said Luke was a little ahead of the band and that his performance was corny. Paula was surprised that Luke picked the song (hey surprises were last week’s theme). Then she pulled a page out of Randy’s book and did a little name dropping. Apparently, Paula choreographed George Michael’s tour. After a little prodding from Simon, Paula managed to get back on track and convey that she liked Luke’s interpretation of the song. Simon’s remarks needed no interpretation; he said he didn’t like Luke’s performance. Simon even called it girly and a bit weak. In closing, Simon boldly predicted that Luke could not make it through, not even to the final 12.

Next up was David Archuletta, whose most embarrassing moment involved him forgetting the words to a song during a performance in Honduras. But no worries, his mom came to the rescue. She jumped on stage and finished the song for him. Talk about your helicopter mom. Poor kid.

David took on Phil Collins’ “Another Day in Paradise”. I liked David A’s piano playing in the beginning of the song, but the rest of the song was all a little too goody -goody for me. Not to mention that he was singing off key.

Randy said it was like watching David at one of his concerts. What? Has he attended one too? Randy added that it was an interesting song choice, because it didn’t show off David’s vocal prowess. Randy also pointed out that there were a couple of pitch problems during the performance. Whereas other contestants would have been chided for singing out of tune, David was actually praised for it. Paula said she liked that there were a few notes off pitch because it proved he wasn’t a hologram or perfect. I guess that means he won’t be walking on water next week.

Thank good ness Simon managed to remain somewhat objective about the crowned prince of Idol. He told David that the performance wasn’t as good as last week’s and that it was a little gloomy. Simon also advised David to lighten up. Since he’ll probably make it to the final 2, Simon said it would be nice to occasionally see a slightly different or fun side of David.

Danny Noriega followed David. And Danny’s most embarrassing moment occurred when a friend of his tripped him, in front of one of his crushes. Danny sang the song “Tainted Love”, which in theory should have been a good song for him. I mean I thought he was really going to work it. But he was stuck in the middle, like he was just warming up.  He comes across in his interview and tapes as this flamboyant type of guy (all Ross the intern like), but he doesn’t seem to want to totally commit to the persona when he’s on stage.

Randy cut to the chase and said there were some good things and some bad things. He added that the song started rough, but that he loved the arrangement. Randy also felt like Danny was a little shy with the vocals. Paula described Danny as a bright light in the competition. Simon, on the other hand, thought the whole performance was horrible. He hated everything.

After headlining all of the entertainment television programs earlier this week, David Hernandez had to settle for the fourth spot Tuesday night.  With not even a nod to the controversy that is surrounding him, David said his most embarrassing moment was when he discovered a pea (or was it walnut) sized booger in his nose, while viewing proofs from a photo shoot.  Whatever David. I’m sure you’ve experience more awkward situations.

David H’s song from the 80’s, was highly covered hit “It’s All Coming Back to Me Now”. The song is best known as a Celion Dion hit, but was recorded in the 80’s by a girl group called Pandora’s Box. Even though I can no longer imagine David H. singing his songs to me, I still liked his performance. The boy can blow.

Randy said David made a nice song choice, because he has a big old voice. However, Randy told David that he sometimes overshoots the note. Paula said felt like David was getting into the groove and finding his niche. She threw in her belief that David had some of the best vocals.  Simon said David’s performance was not as good as last week’s. Simon also expressed his preference for when David does soul songs. With all that said, Simon said that David had 100% secured a place in next week’s finals. I tend to agree with Simon. That is unless of course, David gets booted from the show a la Frenchy Davis style.

I also want to add that David Hernandez was getting on my nerves. I know he was thanking his luck stars that the show had not kicked him off and that the judges didn’t bring up his past days as a stripper, but he was laying it on a little thick with all the thank yous after each comment.

David Cook was supposed to appear after David Hernandez, but there were some technical difficulties with his guitar. As a result, Michael Johns was fifth to perform.  Michael’s most embarrassing moment was being beat up in front of 20,000 people, by four guys, while dressed like a kangaroo at a rugby game in Australia. Michael said even if he didn’t make it to the final 12, he wanted to take the opportunity to show America what kind of artist he would be. He said the record he would make, would be a rock/soul one. I think the senior member of the crew might also be the wisest.

Michael performed the song “Don’t You (Forget About Me)” a hit tune from the movie the “The Breakfast Club”. I think he sang a little off key, but it was enjoyable nonetheless.

Randy exclaimed “Aussie boy goes home”. Then he compared Michael to Michael Huthcence, the former, now deceased, lead singer of INXS and fellow Australian. Paula loved the strength in Michael’s lowe range. Simon said he liked Michael’s performance, but didn’t love it. Simon also expressed his belief that Michael was a huge talent, but like Carly, Simon said Michael had not connected with the right song nor has his moment. Simon threw in that he preferred Michael as a soul singer as opposed to a rock singer.

David Cook finally got the issues with his guitar worked out. And no surprise his most embarrassing moment involved forgetting the words to a song he was singing during a talent show. Well there was no need for embarrassment during his performance on AI7, because David C. took a classic pop song and put a whole new spin on it. David sang the hit “Hello”, by one of my favorite singer/songwriters Mr. Lionel Ritchie.

With the exception of “Dancing on the Ceiling”, I personally feel like Mr. Ritchie’s songs are perfect as they are. But after David got past the first “hello” in the song, I really started to get into his rendition.  Randy also like the arrangement and he said he felt it could be a hit. Paula said she loved when David comes to the stage, because she knows she is going to be surprised. Simon said it was a very brave thing for David to do, but that he loved it.  Simon also said he hoped to see David C. next week. As soon as the kind words left Simon’s lips a wave of relief passed over David, proving that Simon’s opinion is the only one that really matters.

 Jason Castro appeared next to last and he said he is most embarrassing moment happened while he was on a date, with a girl (you know this year you have to spell it out). Jason said he put his hands in his hair and one of his dreads broke off. The story has a happy ending though, because he got to go on another date with the girl.

In my opinion, Jason gave the best performance of the night. He sang the classic “Hallelujah” by Leonard Cohen.

Randy praised Jason for taking on a song with a great deal of difficulty and doing a pretty good job with it. Paula said Jason made the song sound effortless. She also said she was glad Jason showed a beautiful vulnerability. Finally she called his performance unique and differently recognizable. Simon revealed that the Jeff Buckley version of the song was one his favorite songs of all time. Then Simon told Jason he thought the performance was arguably one of the best of the night.

Chikezie closed the show this week. Chikezie’s embarrassing moment occurred in high school. He said he use to go to the same bathroom every day because it was so clean. Until one day the door to the bathroom was closed and Chikezie saw that it had “Women’s” written on it. He always wondered why there were no urinals in the bathroom.

Chikezie selected a song best known as a Whitney Houston song, “He Fills Me Up”, although he did try to provide a litany of other artist that performed the song. I personally thought Chikezie did a good job with the song, but Simon felt that since it was a Whitney song he shouldn’t have touched it. Simon did at least tell Chikezie that he was okay in bits. Paula believed Chikezie’s vocals sound really good. Randy thought it was an interesting song and that he did a good job with a tough song.

When prompted by host Ryan Seacrest, Randy also said he thought Chikezie deserved a spot in the finals. If that’s true, that means Luke Menard and Danny Noreiga are out. But something tells me we haven’t seen the last of Danny, so I honestly believe Chiekzie will be set freezy.